When we think of skills, we generally think of things we learn in school, use in daily life, or develop through our work. We think of math, changing the oil in a car, or starting an IV. We tend to think less about introspection, thoughtfulness, or emotional fluency as skills. Yet these are also things we can teach and learn, and they may be among the most important skills we develop.
This comes up often in my work with people in recovery from substance use. When we have feelings we cannot identify, express, or figure out how to respond to, we become uncomfortable. For some people, substances become a way to numb that discomfort. When the substance use stops, the feelings remain. We are left with the same problem we had before: what to do with all the emotions we never learned how to manage.
I notice this in particular with men. As a man, I see three emotions that are generally socially acceptable for us to express. We are allowed and expected to get angry. When things go wrong, there is a social expectation that men will express their anger through words or actions. Second, we are allowed to be frustrated. This is a close cousin of anger, and often becomes the catchall response when things are not going as we would like. Third, in certain circumstances, we are allowed to feel pride. This is acceptable in the context of family and accomplishments, particularly at work. But expressing pride in our own accomplishments can quickly be interpreted as arrogance or being big-headed. If we make a play in sports that wins the game, we are expected to credit our teammates. If we complete a large project at work, we are expected to downplay its significance.
We live in a culture that often encourages self-promotion, competition, and putting ourselves first, yet we also teach men to minimize their own accomplishments. We are allowed to pursue success, but expected to be modest about feeling good about it.
This relates to another expectation around men's emotions: that they should be controlled. In practice, this often means keeping them out of sight. Being governed by our emotions—any of them—is not acceptable. We can manage them, suppress them, or keep them in check, but we are less often encouraged to feel them or understand them. When men experience difficulty, we are expected to be strong or stoic with respect to what we feel; in this context, that is a synonym for absent.
It is tempting to blame men for these patterns, but that misses the point. If emotional fluency is a learnable skill, then we also have to consider what happens when no one teaches it. Most of us learned what we know about emotions by watching the men around us. We learned from our fathers, who learned from theirs. We learned from our peers, from the reactions of people around us, and from the expectations of the workplaces and communities we grew up in. Few of these men set out to teach us to limit our emotional lives. They were simply passing along what they had learned themselves. What looks like an individual failure is, in part, a pattern that has been reproduced across generations.
There are consequences to having such a limited emotional vocabulary. Imagine trying to describe the world using only three colors: red, blue, and yellow. The grass might be yellowish-blue, and the sunset might be red-yellow. Without words for green, orange, purple, or pink, accurately describing the world becomes difficult. If we have only a handful of words to describe how we feel, our ability to make sense of sadness, disappointment, relief, or insecurity is limited. When we experience an emotion we don't know how to name, we may call it something we do recognize. Disappointment and sadness might become anger, fear might become frustration. Alternatively, we may learn to turn our feelings off. In situations where it would make sense to feel a lot, we learn how to feel a little.
This framework of three emotions is an oversimplification and an exaggeration, but a useful one. All frameworks and heuristics reveal some truths while obscuring others. Even when our emotional repertoire extends well beyond three emotions, those three may still dominate how we understand and express ourselves.
If we lack the ability to recognize a feeling, we don't stop having those feelings. We simply experience and express them through the limited vocabulary we have. This can help explain why we sometimes respond in ways that don't make much sense. Suppose our child hurts someone else at school. Rather than recognizing that we feel disappointed, discouraged, or embarrassed, we might experience only anger or frustration. Anger might be appropriate to some extent, but it is incomplete.
Or suppose our partner says something that hurts us: "I feel like I have to do everything myself. I can't rely on you." We might feel rejected, insecure, or inadequate. But if we don't recognize those emotions, the nearest available response may be anger or frustration: "I've done X, Y, and Z, but you didn't even notice," or "Nothing's ever good enough for you." We experience instant anger and frustration. The bafflement at the original comment is genuine. Because the underlying emotional landscape is difficult to navigate, we’ll often unconsciously switch to logical thinking, calmly pointing out the rational reasons the other person is wrong—while sidestepping our own emotional hurt. We can justify our reaction without actually understanding it. Learning to name our emotions does not fix every problem, but we can't navigate feelings we cannot even recognize.
This is a skill we can learn, just like changing the oil in a car. I'm not much of a mechanic because working on cars is not a skill I've developed. If someone showed me how to change brake pads, I could do it. I'd be slow and awkward at first, but with repetition I'd become more comfortable and capable. The same goes for emotional identification. When we first try to identify and understand our feelings, the process can feel awkward and unnatural. It takes concentration and conscious effort. With practice, it becomes more familiar.
Pausing to identify what we're feeling can be useful practice. We don't need to wait for something significant to happen. We can practice while brushing our teeth or washing the dishes. In the office, I often give people a long list of emotions and ask them to identify as many as they can in a given moment. This is hard at first. It feels awkward, uncomfortable, or even silly. But repetition helps. We become more familiar with the language, and more capable of recognizing what is happening inside us.
When we can identify what we're feeling, we gain a better understanding of ourselves and more choices about how to respond. We can name disappointment rather than turning it into anger, or acknowledge insecurity without disguising it as defensiveness. This matters for our own well-being, and for our relationships. When we understand what is happening inside us, we are better able to communicate it to the people around us, rather than leaving them to respond to emotions we haven't learned to recognize ourselves. Emotional fluency doesn't mean feeling less. It means understanding ourselves better, and having more ways to engage with the people and world around us.
Love,
Doc
Forwarded this email? Sign-up here
See past posts here.